ࡱ> y RXbjbj9{{a  6:p,8$ dGp:rPLHGJGJGJGJGJGJG$JcMXnG!000nG4G6969690HG690HG6969rBTB?62VB4GG0GdB2M8XMBBNMDP006900000nGnGZ8000G0000M000000000 , : -NVNN?eV{ST^ZP͑'Yte Nvcr^^:W0RXۏNibU\^:W _lޘm NgSf Q[c21N~Neg -NVNN?eV{ۏNek:_SNL?e'`r^cevЏ(u SOsQ:_pvvcr^^:Wyr_06q 'Yϑxvze.shf Nvcr^^:W:Nyr_v b'`NN?eV{ evQtOnc؏/f[eHegS0R^lv(u0,ge(W͑eƋ^:W:g6RN ^:W1Yup vW@x N ۏNekS`NN?eV{vtW@xN?eV{ST0(WSU\TlWV[X[(Wv@b ^:W1Yup [RY/f ?e^1Yup b 6R^1Yup [evcr^^:WWvNN?eV{SOOf:N%N͑0,ge(WPt^:WXۏTmeQc?e^N^:WsQ|vW@x N ՋVg^NN?eV{ev`Fhg sS:NN?eV{^S_N~b^:WzN0Xۏ^:W:gNibU\^:WV\O:NW,gST v^NdkOۏNNNVl~NmveP^SU\0 N0_ gNeg NN?eV{NTyt1u^lX[(WN-NV~NmTW-N0ۏeQ21N~ -NV?e^Џ(uNN?eV{Kbk[N_‰~Nm;mRvr^f>fR:_02000t^Neg -NVvNN?eV{QNNmv@b gNN fY0Whs:N[NNQyr[ON0yr[b/g0yr[NTv b'`vbcNS[NN~~b_`vc02009t^ -NVF~^[eAS'Y͑pNNteN/ctQĉR NKNMWYv[e~RY160YOy mS0RNN;mRvT*Neb0͑pNNte/ctQĉRSvQ[e~Rv^[e asT@wёqS:gNT?e^?eV{ۏNek:_SNNN?eV{vЏ(u0N?eV{v[eKbk Neg w vU_c[0^:WQeQ0yv[ybN8hQ0O0W[yb07>kvL?e8hQ0:_6R'`ntmpl=TN I{L?e'`vcr^ceۏNek:_S [_‰~Nmvr^f:N^l0~Tvc N SOsQ:_pvvcr^^:W0P6R^:WzNTN?e^ bNf^:W:g6Rv{6R'`yr_TSmSvR~Nmri__lޘm NgSf 2010 0 6q ُyP6R^:W0r^^:WNfN^:WvNN?eV{!j_ e(WtOnc؏/fwQSO[eHegvƋ Nb4N%N\vcbT(u0ُ{|?eV{v!P[:N :NN%_eSU\eg'YϑX[(WvNOSDnRXT0bDRMTOۏb/gvvsQv ^:W1Yup ?e^_{fN^:W[eNN?eV{[~Nm;mRۏLr^0~gq\lQ~1998 [ُN‰pcQN9h,g'`(uuNS'`/f1uBlt'`v~Nm;NSO'YϑՋNTSsv l gNnxRwS~NmSU\vLu(WT?Q g}Y^[Y7hSvOSՋX[(W NMQǏSs~NmSU\fؚXLuv:gO S_Ǒ(uN?e^v b0r^egNf^:WvOS[e HNSsf[Hes:g6RvS'`_N\'Y:NQ\0NLuL1991 [vcr^^:W:g6RN0Rwck^:W1YupvZPlcQ(u?e^TvQN~NmSN T7hb4NoRTOo`~_g N?e^:NOo`NAmvZN[s[g;mRvOS *g_0Rwck^:W1Yupvvv v^N(Wb/gMRofT^:W:gOX[(W Nnx['`v`Q N S O[?e^1Yup0Z\ ( Powell 2005)cQ ?e^elNf^:Weg cknx b^b N^SU\vNNbb/gI{ V:N cknx b@bvwƋS g(W^:WvzNǏ z-NMbNuT_ vQ-NRcevyNOo`/f NR;`0~T(uN~Nm{v0(Wr^^:W0fN^:WvNN?eV{!j_ N ?e^KNN'Yϑr^_‰~Nm;mRNRMDnvCgR ?eV{蕾NMQ:_'Y)RvƖVv8nNq_T _NNMQ?eV{蕊bNN?eV{\O:N Blꁫ)RvvKbk0@wl;NRϑ(WNNvSU\ ?e^[_‰~Nmr^@b[v'YϑP%_Nf2eWl ^_R$\ }y 2003 0 ^eI{N( Hobbs et al. 1991)RۏNekcQ SU\-NV[vnxX[(W@w^:W1Yup FOُ;N/f?e^r^v~g0^:WSO|OۏHesvR ;`/fS0R^:WЏL@bVNOX[v6R^SO|v6R~ @b ^:W1Yup v^^^:W,gX[(WQ(W@\PN N vQ[((WN^:WVNX[(Wv6R^MRcKN1Y%s^` 2005 0-NVs6kNYN~NmlWǏ z-N ^:W:g6Rv^ N[U Y wfWXR ?eV{ce_Nf:NwQSO [^:Wvvcr^f>fR:_0 1NN?eV{v;NNR 2000t^Neg -NVNN?eV{vNR;NƖ-N(WOۏNN~gteTb6RRLNǏ^bD0NǏiR$N*Neb0NvNeg OۏNN~gvte1\/f-NVNN?eV{v͑NRKNN ۏeQ21N~NT ?eV{fR͑ƉNN~gte Y?eV{/fV~OۏNN~gte 6R[0OY 0S_MRV[͑pRSU\vNN0NTTb/gvU_2000t^O 00 0OۏNN~gtevfLĉ[ 00 0}lfNNSU\?eV{ 00 0NNSU\?eV{ 00 04ll]NNNSU\?eV{ 00AS'Y͑pNN~gte/ctQĉRI{I{/fbNN~gte>e(Wg:N͑vMOn N0 N TN20N~80090t^NNN?eV{(WVl~Nm-Nc ͑pSU\NNb/egNNvZPl 2000t^NegvNN?eV{(WOۏNN~gte-N f:NsQlv/fNNQ~gte0 0S_MRV[͑pRSU\vNN0NTTb/gvU_2000t^O 0mS0R28*NW QNNmvNVl~Nm-N@b g'Y{|LN v^(WُN'Y{|LN-N~RQN526yRSU\vNT0b/gSRW@xeT gRyv 0NN~gtec[vU_2005t^,g 0R{|-NqQmS0R26*NW T7hQNNmvNVl~Nm-N@b g'Y{|LN v^R{|RQN539yRSU\vNTTyv0V ُ$N*NvU_;N/fc[TLNQ萄vNTGS~Tb/gSU\ fYv/fOۏTNNQ萄v~gte0T SU\9eiYS^NNLNv~gtec[a ۏNekR:_N[NLNNN~gtevc[0NF~^vNN?eV{eNeg w NN~gte;NƖ-N(WLNQNT~gte0NN~~~gte0NN^@\teNSNNb/gGS~V*Neb NN~~~gteSNib'YORONĉ!j0cؚƖ-N^:N8h_0bN N wQ яt^egNN?eV{-N NN~gte KNN^lvmIN QNNmvNNN?eV{TebvQ[0 2003t^Neg RLNvvvbDNNǏiR_w?eV{蕄vؚ^sQl ?e^v~QSNN|RvNN?eV{Nb6RُNLNvvvbDTNǏiR0OY2003t^11g V[SU\9eiYXTOI{qQ T6R[v 0sQN6RbkLNvvbDvr^a 00 0sQN6Rbk5uݔLNݏĉ^vvbDvr^a 00 0sQN2bk4llLNvvbDR_~gtevr^a 02006t^ VRbS^ 0VRbsQNR_cۏNǏiRLN~gtew 0 T V[SU\9eiYQSN 0V[SU\9eiYsQN}lf]N~gteavw 00 0sQNLNc6R;`ϑmpl=TR_~gtevw 0I{?eV{2009t^9g V[SU\9eiYQS 0sQNb6RRLNNǏiRT͑ Y^_[NNeP^SU\vr^a 0 Nlt04ll0s^gstI{LNvNǏiR0 2NN?eV{v;Nce 2000t^NegNN?eV{ Neb:_S%c^:W(WDnMn-NvW@x'`\O(u NebS:_R:_V[NN?eV{v_[ vU_c[0^:WQeQ0yv[ybN8hQ0O0W[yb07>kvL?e8hQ0:_6R'`nt(mpl=TN)I{L?e'`vcr^ceۏNek:_S mS^:WSO6R9ei0Oۏ^:W:g6Rf}Y0WS%cDnMnRvwQSO?eV{cev[\0 1 (W21N~NegvNN?eV{-N,vU_c[/fNy͑v?eV{ce02000t^^N 0S_MRV[͑pRSU\vNN0NTTb/gvU_2000t^O 0 1999^2007t^gv~S^NV*NHr,g 0S_MROHQSU\vؚb/gNNS͑pWcWS 0 ُ/fR{|vc[vU_1999^2002t^gv~S^v Nyb 0mpl=TuNR0]zTNTvvU_ 0R/fmpl{|vU_02005t^^ 0NN~gtec[vU_2005t^,g 0ۏNek~RRNR{|0P6R{|Tmpl{|vvU_ 9hnc 0OۏNN~gtevfLĉ[ 0 [NRvNTTyv vsQ(Wyv[ybN8hQ0O70z6e NNNN[v/ecP6R{|ve^yvRybkbD bD{t NN[yb ё:gg N_cO7>k W0W N_O0WI{I{mplyv NFOybkbD T0T0W:ST gsQONǑS gRce cgqĉ[Pgmpl02009t^NegcLv͑pNNteN/ctQĉR-N \te 0NN~gtec[vU_ 0T 0YFUNNbDNNc[vU_ 0\O:N$Ny͑vQ[01udkS -NVS_MR[evvU_c[܏܏ NS/f c[ HN{US /fvcNyv[ybT8hQ0O7S0z6eO`NW0WO`?eV{vSI{'}[vsQ TeP6R{|vU_Tmpl{|vU_wQ g:_6R'`[evyr'`0V (W-NVvNN?eV{-N vU_c[/fwQ g:_pvcr^^:W'`(v?eV{ce0 2 bD[ybN8hQT^:WQeQ/f-NVcLNN?eV{wQ g:_~_gRv͑Kbk02004t^ 0sQNbDSO6R9eivQ[ 0N 0?e^8hQvbDyvvU_ 0R:N?eV{蕡[8hT{tTNNQvONbDcONOnc ُybD8hQ_Nb:NcLNN?eV{v͑ce0(W 0NNSU\?eV{ 0T 0}lfNNSU\?eV{ 0-N bD8hQTLNQeQ[NcLNN?eV{wQ g͑\O(u0NNSU\?eV{-N /f&T_bD8hQ/f%NcW0WT7>kv/UNhQ02006t^v 0VRbsQNR_cۏNǏiRLN~gtew 0T2009t^^v 0sQNb6RRLNNǏiRT͑ Y^_[NNeP^SU\vr^a 0-N %NfWR:_ 6R[N%NfR:_  [‰cNL?ec:N;N b:Nck_vc[e4Tlet 2009 0b6RRLNvvvbD0NǏiR/fNN?eV{v͑Q[ Te_N/f [‰c ?eV{v͑~bR (Wb6RNǏiRvNN?eV{-NL?evcr^_‰^:Wvcef>f:_S ُyR Te_NSOs(WT6R[vNNSU\?eV{0NN~gte?eV{T͑pNNte/ctQĉR-N02003t^ ?e^S^v 0sQN6RbkLNvvbDvr^a 00 0sQN6Rbk5uݔLNݏĉ^vvbDvr^a 0T 0sQN2bk4llLNvvbDR_~gtevr^a 0 ُ N*Na>fW:_SNُ N*NLNvyv[ybTLNQeQ6R^ v^BlVW0L%NfWR:_02006t^Neg N|Rb6RRLNNǏiR0OۏNǏiRLNNN~gtevN|R?eV{-N LNQeQTbD8hQ0[ybۏNekR:_  L?ec ۏNek:_S0 ͑pNNte/ctQĉR^~Nvcr^_‰^:Wvyr_0 096NNteT/ctQĉR 00 0NNteT/ctQĉR 00 0 grё^\NNteT/ctQĉR 0-Nĉ[ NQ8hQb/ecUS~e^0ib^yv 0NNteT/ctQĉR 0T 0 grё^\NNteT/ctQĉR 0؏ĉ[@b gyv_{Nmpl=T:NMRc0mpl@b=TN_N;N`L?eKbkcL 0NNte/ctQĉR 0T 0 grё^\NNteT/ctQĉR 0:_v %Ne7>kvhQ0(W 0b6RRLNNǏiRT͑ Y^_[NNeP^SU\r^a 0-NfecQǑS_vL?eKbk [E NُN?eV{[e;NOVL?eKbk0 -NVNN?eV{:_r^_‰~Nmvyr_ ؏SOs(W?eV{(WNNLN[eP6RzNv?eV{ sSObTvbc(WMOv'YWON$\vQ/f-N.YON P6R-N\ON[(WMO'YON^:W0WMOvcbTzN0[eُ{|?eV{__N EQR)R(uĉ!j~Nm Sb wQ gVEzNRv'YWONƖVcؚ^:WƖ-N^ MQǏ^zN :Nt1u0ُ{|?eV{vZPl g6R[ g)RN(WMO'YWONvLNSU\ĉR6R[ g)RN'YWONSU\TP6R-N\ONSU\vyv[ybb8hQagN6R[ g)RN(WMO'YWONvQeQagNb%NPTNvQ͑pvbcv'YWONƖV ĉ!jeu\v}lfONe(W_TD[ybv:gO N؏/fTDvVS0Rg'Y0WP6R0 N0?e^vcr^WNN?eV{!P[vW,g‰pTOnc 20N~60t^NNeg Ne,g0V0-NVS~n:NNhvNNV[T0W:SVl~Nmc~ؚX _wVE>yOv^lsQl NLuLyKN:N NNGY 0NN'YRV[T0W:S[eNygr^~Nm:Nyr_vNN?eV{  NNGY e(WY'`I{_‰eb bbeQNQebv-N‰Rg WadevRg͑p>e(WfR:go}Yv?e^(WOۏNNSU\ebvf[`NWvc[҉r v^^hQwhQvc[ ۏNek[?e^ ~m^:W vR:gegn0?e^OR@b(W0?eV{vSO^v^zI{ebۏLRg NSNN?eV{T~Nm~HeKNvvsQ'`vc0(WWade weg S~n0VTe,gNSeRaWI{GW[eNvf fv/f beu'`8ft>f6qv^l g:N-NV_vcr^T{6RVQ_‰~Nm ^:WvNN?eV{cOvctOnc0 2  ^:W1Yup vsQt  ^:W1Yup SvQvsQt/f?e^vcr^WNN?eV{g:N͑vtW@x0NeSxQ~Nmf[-NN,GWat NSNdkt`r`[k N;TTvr`ċ$R:N ^:W1Yup sS(W^:W~NmagN N 1uNY'`0^:WRR0Oo` N[YTlQqQirTI{ NǏ1uzN[sDnvOSMn (Wdk`Q N ?e^NNN?eV{\O:N]wQr^^:WNw0R~ck^:WNOHesv\O(u0Stiglitz1993 I{N؏ۏNekcQ 1uN^:W1YupYOo` N[y N[hQzN Y'`I{ (Wё^:WvX[(WkvQN^:Wf:N^l ё^:W NoЏLv#N(WN?e^{6R NS_ ?e^[ё^:WvTtr^ NNSNOۏё^:Wf g^Џl NSNcO3z[v[‰~NmsX [steSO~Nm~Hevcؚ0[Nё^:WSNNSU\ ?e^r^/f_v ͑p(WNYUO6R[S_vr^vhNSr^]wQvTt gHe)R(u0 sNNN?eV{tbU\N O~ ^:W1Yup t :NN,aIN NX[(W$Ny{|Wv^:W1Yup OS1Yup T Oo`Yn ck/f1uNX[(Wُ$Ny^:W1Yup ^:WMbel[DnۏL gHevMn MbNu?e^Џ(uNN?eV{v0Hausman and Rodrik 2003 0Pack and Westphal(1986):N]NSۏ z-N(WOۏbDebX[(W^lvёY'` (WbDKNۏLfnxvOSN[sNQgO0Okuno-Fujiwara(1988)cNWNY'`X[(W@bt+Tv?eV{aIN :N?e^SNǏcOOo`NAmNOSwQ gY'`vvsQ Y'`TOS1Yupv^lX[(WasT@w?e^(W]NSǏ z-NۏL'Yϑr^v_'`0Rodrik1996 l@wOkuno-Fujiwarav; ^zv^!jWf N N8n ONKNX[(WbDNe'`e sSS_N[ONbD6evSQNvQ[bD/f&TbDe SOQsOS1Yup`Q (Wt N?e^SNǏgbLNN?eV{_[^:W;NSOǑSgNL:N uNf^:WvcgbLgybD0FO/f Rodrik TecQ ?e^(W㉳QOS1Y% ۏLr^e_{c(Nav`^ V:NǏ?e^r^㉳QOS1Y% /fN*NQivV{eu$Re 0 (WsNNN?eV{t weg Oo`Yn/f[^:W1YupvSN͑SV0Hausman and Rodrik (2003)yr+R:_NSSsself-discovery Ǐ z-NvwƋYn sSON(Wd[uNgyeNTvb,g~gǏ z-NOQswƋYn S_ONSsv)R:gOv^[sv)Re \OvQ[vۏeQ!jN S_ۏL\ՋvONSs Nv)Re ON_{bb@b gvd[b,g0ckVYdk ۏLReONv6ev\NON>yO6ev ^:W:NۏL SSs vRe;mRcOvoR N0vQ?eV{+TIN/f?e^^S_e4Re OvQ6eeQN>yO6eeQv;TT0ybxS-NX[(WvckY'`/fNyxQWvOo`Yn Nv/fTV[yx;mR[e/ec?eV{v͑SV0яt^eg @wyb(WsN~NmSU\-N@bwv\O(ueg͑ SV[fR͑ƉǑ(uR'`NN?eV{Oۏyf[b/gvxvzT_S0Pack and Saggi2001 cQ?e^^;NǏ[ON(WۏLR ewƋ0Ssf}YvuNb/geb~Ne4 ~NONfYeT:gONSse`lTewƋbeb/gv>N

eceTQScRV{eu0P傡l g?e^v b'`r^ e$NVv~Nm_NSU\vf_0(W[‰~Nm3z[0Gls3z[0ؚPĄTؚbDI{agN N ?e^[_‰~NmۏLr^ g_cN~NmSU\(Trezise 1983Wolf 2007)0Krugman1997 R:N NN~NmSU\v;NSV(WN?e^ygcRNRD,gbDTcGS v^^N2m?e^(WcGSyr[NNTb/gebvZPlN[ N N2m?e^9h,g NwS](WZPNHN0Heo and Kim2000 T7h(uNNvcr^^:Wv?eV{!j_ }6qNNbNN?e^SU\NRDn0cR_>eT/ecQSOۏN~NmSU\ FO/fNNۏNekcQ?e^Ǐ[eNN?eV{NՋV0R[c vyrpNNۏLvb i NNl gbR NkeN

fSS0NN$N1988 :N [Ne,g NNvSU\}6qYN?e^vSRKN N FOW,g N/fu_^:W:g6RMb_NSU\v0NN?eV{S/fNOb/ecNN^:W:g6R:NW@xvEQn;mRv~NmSU\ iIv 1984 0 YV[e,gNN?eV{v[ErQTHegnfMX[(W@wċNOPؚv>PT \[*YΐI{ 1988 0 2 e,gv^l g[e@bygr^^:WvNN?eV{0[Nr^^:WWNN?eV{v/ec  NN?eV{ gHeS%c\O(u [bTe,g~NmvؚSU\ZPQ]'Y!.s /fg:N͑vN[Onc06q ُ*N@bvN[OncS(WSS N9h,g1\ NfSuǏ0 Nnΐ(2002)(WvQW\O 0e,gNN?eV{v 0-N [N NN?eV{ gHeS%c\O(u [bTe,g~NmvؚSU\ZPQ]'Y!.s v‰_SvQN[Onc ۏL~v㉐gTh :Nُ*N‰_/fl g9hncv^NN[ N&{vl0 Nnΐ[N~Nm?eV{S[vxvzhf Nwv^l g[l~Nm;NSO[e gHev^wQ g͑'Yq_TRv?eV{Kbke,g?e^[N[evcr^^:Wv?eV{b@wgvQ(Nav`^QNTy TSv NN?eV{ (WQNN@b g`Q N NN:ONfnxwQSOv ?eV{vh v^N:\SO[ev?eV{Kbke,gv^l g[ev^yKN:N NN?eV{ vr^;NIN?eV{ /fǏ1u~Nm^:W [sNbT~NmvؚX0 NnΐۏNekcQ (WgyaIN Neg e,gv NN?eV{ v^ N/f1Y%N /fN*gwck[eǏ0 3 vcr^^:WWvNN?eV{[ NoHeg0NNxvzuhf r^^:WWvNN?eV{ NFO N/fcRNNSU\v;NSV ؏[ Nov?eV{vTg0 OCQ͑1984 :N\Nf[/gLuvz:Weg w [NN?eV{X[(WvaINfWvq_T [5ul0(u:ghNSNЏ:ghI{LN NN?eV{[uNs؏NuNbvq_T0zQؚ[(2002) (W 0NN?eV{v 0NfN-N [e,g(WVE NbRv20yNNT1Y%v7yNNۏLN~kT _N:Ne,gbRvNN'YYl gNN?eV{v/ec 1Y%vNNp`p`/fNN?eV{{_gǏY0yr+R/fP6RzNYv0 2-NVNN?eV{v[eHeg T7hb4N%N͑v(u -NVNN?eV{v[eHeg T7hNN(u0_l\m1999 cQ-NV[e?e^r^WNN?eV{vHegY Nt` YLNؚSU\vǏ z 1\/f Nez4x gsQ蕄Km01yvQĉR0Fd1vQr^vǏ z Yg?e^vr^'YR_N[s ُNLNvSU\1\OۏNek^ߏ0Ngs^0{lT_lޘm2012 Ǒ(uON_‰penchf vcr^^:WNP6RzNvNN?eV{O_0}lf0wS096I{͑LNO܀Rpl:g6RNS%c\O(u v^%N͑;xُNLNHesvۏNekcؚ0_lޘmI{N2007 0RN&(2008)0&qVNSI{N2007 0_lޘm2008 0Ngs^I{N2010 0f^wmT_lޘm2010 I{NNcQ-NVr^WvNN?eV{Hegv^ Nt` v^[N Nov?eV{He^ v^TcQNv^vtOncT~xvzOnc0[N-NVNN?eV{[eHegv(u SN;`~:NN NQp 1 ǑS^lr^_‰~NmvNN?eV{ &^eg:N%N͑[yTP%L:N RgR6eeQRMv Ns^a v^MNOteSO~NmSO|v;mR0[_‰~Nmv^lr^ g'Y0Wib'YNL?eRϑMnDnvRTKbk :_SN-NV[y;mRv6R^W@x [yĉ!jN Neib'Y P%safR%N͑0ĉ!j]'Yvyё;`ϑ>fWRgRN-NV>yOv+[]ݍ 'YϑyёvX[(W؏mbfNONvL:N [ON~%\fYv|RMnN[y;mR v^vQ\N^^:W0MNOb,g0cؚNT(ϑ0_SeNTI{ebvRR ۏ MNONteSO~NmSO|v_‰;mR0 2 -NV(W}lf00wSI{͑LN[e%NfWvbq_T0Ǒ(u]NON_‰pencv[xvzhf ُN?eV{O_}lf0wS0096I{LN-NO܀Rpl:g6R%N͑S; N)RNLNHesv9eۏ ُhs(WN N N*Neb`$(WMO'YON1uNS?eV{vbcN:ONzNSR uNHesOPNON9eۏba FO^:WNtS Neib'Ya$NNwQ gؚuNHesNHes9eۏ^_v-N\ONbeۏeQON FOS?eV{P6RtSNۏNekbTib'Y^:WNb$1uN^:WzNSP NNNOHesvONgX[;m(W^:W-N NmplQ^:W0؏cQv/f N_vbD[ybT8hQdu`sXObKNY ؏;xNON[^:WBlXT~gSRZPQŏS^ ~ON~%NSNT~gte&^egV _N&^egy0[yI{N|R ۏNekMNOLNteSOHes0 3 vU_c[b:N?eV{Nꁫv$ReT begNf^:W:g6Rv]wQ [ No?eV{Heg0vU_c[[( N/f?eV{NT*NLN-Nc Q͑pSU\vHQۏb/g0]zTNTۏLvb i v^c Q=Tvb/g0]zTNTۏLP6RTmpl ?eV{[ N~v*N~RLN-NOYb/g0]zTNTvMRof0~Nm'`N^:WYۏLQnxv$ReTKm ُ/fNy?eV{9h,g NS[bv]\O0vU_c[?eV{6R[T[e-N__bV~NmSU\6k GrbBlSU\ؚeb/gNTT]z Teb,gegwQ g^:WBlvN w\O=TNNv^RNmpl0OY яt^egYvfEx0Θ5uY6R NvNǏiR LNRؚzNTYRǏiRNSMRNt^1uNP6R~Pg0~NI{NOzNTv?eV{ [^Q{Pg^:WO^v[w:0vU_c[^͑(Wc[ sS:NONcOsQN*geg^:WTNNSU\Rv͑Oo` ^[ONRN_[ N^wQ g:_6RR0 4 Grb:_^:WƖ-N^0ONĉ!j ['YϑNOHes͑~L:N0-NV(W͑LN[evNN~~?eV{SOۏ|Qv^͑~?eV{ GW\cؚ^:WƖ-N^TSb 'Yĉ!jON\O:Ng:N͑v?eV{vv N?eV{Yebvbc'YONv^P6R\ON0ُy?eV{!j_['Yϑ0We?e^;N[[^^:W[Tv|Qv^͑~ ُN͑~'YYHesNO0ُy?eV{!j_\^:W~gN^:W~He{US[^ _euN^:WzNǏ z\O:NN*N[{ :g6RTSsǏ z wQYHesORvONYuX[TSU\ ^:WN;`N:ONHesvONly0RfwQHesvON 1y_ُNǏ z S:_Ɩ-N^0ONĉ!jvHes/fkeaINv0[N|Qv^͑~?eV{ ^mSƖ-N^TONĉ!jvh0vQg:N͑vaIN^(WNǏgQ{ g)RN|Qv^͑~v6R^T^:WsX 9eUT:_S^:WvO܀Rpl:g6R cؚ^:WvteSOHes :NNNvlWGS~cOo}Yv^:WsX0ՋVǏ?e^;N[bcRv|Qv^͑~eg[sNNlWGS~vvh [R/f/fbׂR0 5 Nr^_‰~Nmve_ltNǏiRX[(W9h,g:w v^O&^eg No?eV{He^0gNeg bV?eV{r^_‰~Nmve_ltNǏiR FOُy?eV{!j_vbR?eV{[*geg^:WZPQQnxvKmT$Re ُNpp`p`/fgN(uv0N20N~90t^NNegY?eV{eN-N[]NNT^:WvKmeg w GWN[E`QX[(W]'Y]_ YgُN?eV{-Nvc6Rvh[s HN\OQs%N͑vO N^Bl0s6k bVvNǏiR;N/fSO6Rmbf N0W:Se4'`zNvNir r^_‰~Nmv?eV{!j_ NFO NN9h,g NltNǏiR S O[^:WOSV0^:WlRRgRI{ Nov?eV{He^0 6 SU\beu'`etQNN?eV{[e-N ǏNl͑e4uNON [RetQNNǏ^bD v^A~mGVYSe4gT6R0яt^eg beu'`etQNN/f?eV{vbcv͑p [NetQNNONv"?e/ecTz6eO`R/f͑-NKN͑ 0We?e^f/fǑSNONO0W0vccO"?ee4I{e_'YRcRbeu'`etQNNSU\06q ُyǏNl͑e4uNONvce vc[YvfEx0Θ5uYI{etQLNQsk%N͑vNǏiR v^[*Y35u`lg0Θ5uYI{NTv~(W'k0^:WmG SS g0f:N͑v/f [NuNONTuNscO'Yϑe4؏OSONv[yL:N N/fbfYvbeQ>e(Wxvz_STb/g]zv9e GS~ N ُ_NOO_etQLN-NON(WVEzN-NfOVN?e^e4TNOalgc>ehQ@b&^egv@bNOb,gzNR0 3. ?e^vcr^WNN?eV{vsQtb4Nv(u NS[?e^vcr^WNN?eV{vxvzeg w ?e^vcr^WNN?eV{(Wt NX[(WN N N*Nebv;N 1 NN?eV{-NX[(WvgO b0Klimenko2004 TLall2001 (u?e^/f&T gRc Qg^SU\vNN0KlimenkocQ ?e^\O:Nb4N%N͑Oo`~_gv?eV{6R[ bvgONNg^SU\vNN __/fv^ NwQ gkORv v^Sg~>e_wQ g wck vkORv^g^SU\vNN0Lall:N1uNwƋv^^YeSxQt@bv~:gh_vOo` Ode_ /fN'Yϑv؞OwƋX[(W v^wQ gƖSO'`0/}y'`T_OVI{yr'` ?e^\b4N%N͑vOo`6R~ N bwck^SU\vNN0?e^v?eV{͑p N^/f(Wc vhNN ^Nl>yOTy%|_dkOS\O W gRN R b[ v^:WsX0 [eNT0b/gT]zv bvNN?eV{ sQNuNb,g0m9OP}Y0_SeNTS[sb/gRev[hQwƋ ُNwƋSO`^:WǏ zvU\_ n>f:yTf2Qeg (W^:WǏ zNuُNOo`KNMRS[/fel[svLavoie 1985 v^NُNwƋwQ gv;N‰'`0yN'`TRce'`0؞ƋvTNyr[ezz gvv /felۏLGl;`vwƋT6KQ 2003 [E N?e^el b^SU\T N^SU\vNN0^_Sb N^_Svb/g ُNS(W^:WzNǏ zS[b_l\m 1996 0 2 ?e^Oo` N[hQT gPt'`0sQNNN?eV{vxvz-N [N?e^[hQOo`T[hQt'`MRcvS[g:N:_p0Krueger1974 :N?e^[s[~Nmv gHer^ _{wQYv^vagN YNlQlg'YS)Rv\O:N?e^vvhQpe0EQROo`vcc0?eV{[eveb,gI{ FO/f_>f6q sN~Nmv YBg'`[Oo`^lce^ Oo`v(ϑv[NOo`vpeϑ fQN N_[~NmQV{#v?e^[XT gHeYtvV0V NN?eV{v gHe'`N_0RO v^N__l:N?e^[yv]wQ0Krueger and Tuncer1982 ۏNekcQ?e^r^SU\f+TvGP[ \lQlvg'YS)Rv~eQvQvhQpe0QV{wQYEQROo`0eb,g1\ScQT[e?eV{ /f Ns[v ?e^r^^;NƖ-N(W]wQ gkORvW sSlQqQTW0 (W[Ev~NmЏL-N ?e^\O:N^:WSN S gPOo`T gPt'`v~_g v^^e(W㉳Qv[hQ-Nzv:gg /fwQ gyr[)RvTRVvQ(WSN NN?eV{6R[Ǐ z-NX[(WYhQnx[V0?e^yOP}Y0?eV{[eKbkVSvQ?eV{[eHegN$ReI{V_l\m 1996R(g ff_ 1998 0wQSO s[~Nm-N 1uNS gPOo`N gHet'`v6R~ ?e^cLNN?eV{vRS0RP6R?e^SꁫRVvqO ۏLr^ S?e^ꁫTONv NS_L:N YyT[yL:N?e^1Yup T7h^lX[(W ^:WNOHesvX[(Wv^ NasT@w[?e^r^v_6q0YeP ck/f?e^[NN;mRv NS_r^ _c[N^:W:g6R\O(uvck8^S%c N [N@bv^:W1Yup0Klinger and Lederman2004 cON|~'`nc cQbSsǏ zvSP z^N1uۏeQXWvX[(WHTckvsQ ?e^[bSsǏ zvP6RNS[1uۏeQvP6RO[OR͑@bv^:W1Yup0 [N?e^Oo` N[hQ fmeQv;N/fWNeY0W)Rf[>mv``0(WeeY0W)Rf[>m~Nmf[ weg (W6R[ b'`(r^^:WW)NN?eV{vǏ z-N sQNuNb,g0m9OP}Y0_SeNTS[sb/gRev[hQwƋ ُNwƋSO`^:WǏ zvU\_ n>f:yTf2Qeg ُNOo`vNuS gǏ^:WǏ zMbY[sLavoie 1985 0 NNYdk Oo`ꁫv؞Ƌ'`T Nnx[wƋvϞ'`sticky knowledge Nyr[v틃Xؚ^vsQ(T6KQ 2003) ُN؞wƋTϞ'`wƋvX[(W_N[wƋ Odv@\W'`TwƋ6eƖvp]'` ?eV{6R[_N NSOncُNwƋۏLcknxv{TKm0 Te ?e^ NSwQ gkONfؚv;NR'`[sOo`v6eƖ0R]T[{ 0(W?e^TvQN~NmSNqQ Tb4NoRTOo`~_g (W?e^ N_eub,gTꁫ)Rvv`Q N[g;mRvOS ՋVwck^:W1Yupvvh__N0R$\vQ/fTON T7hb4Nb/gMRofT^:W:gOX[(W Nnx['`v`Q N S S[?e^[yr[NNvr^b NwNUO\O(ubf:N|| Yb6RON[|^y [^:WNOHesT^:W;mRv:1YI{0 3 beu'`8f?eV{tb4Nv(u0 _OޘT_g32007 ~;`~N(ubeu'`8f?eV{tv;N‰p`$ĉ!j~NmT N[hQzN/fer^;NINvtW@x FO N\[xvzhfُ*NtW@xv^ NbzHobbs 1991Beason and Weinstein 1996 a$d\O NvV0beu'`8f?eV{t-N~QvZS_!jW GP?e^[hQwS@b gv^:WOo`NSONvZS_!j_ [E N?e^/f NSZP0RُNpv %N͑Oo`6R~agN N ?e^ǑSbeu'`8f?eV{S[vSvHegb$[y0beu'`8f?eV{S[ObǏ^TVQ^:WWe v^Sb:N)RvƖV[y]wQ Q\hQSOVlvy)Rc$beu'`8f?eV{[g*Nyr[NNcOObTe4 OXRvQ[NN蕄vb,g ُN蕄v_c1Y_SǏvbcyr[&^egv6evd$[ebX[(Wv$NVX NNV[[evNN?eV{NbV[v^e,g(:S+R Ygbeu'`8f?eV{YʑNN~NmvbR SYUOʑb~Nmv NbR0yr+RcQv/f (WWTOsQNe4TTPIPsOSvĉR N beu'`8f?eV{v;N?eV{]wQP6RۏS0QSe40^Vl_GI{ ]N~~[e0؏ gNpۏNekcQv/f,YgNV[evbeu'`8f?eV{_SvQ[V[ T{|?eV{v[e,HNُy?eV{@bw0R\O(u\g:N gP,v^S[,gVy)R Nv_c1YHelpman and Krugman 1989 0 4mm N T{|WvNN?eV{[ NS_v?eV{ SN*NmƉ҉-Nv^:W:g6RN ^:W1Yup  ^:W1Yup SvQvsQt/fsNNN?eV{tv͑~bR0@weSxQ~Nmf[nb:N-NV~Nmf[v;NAmNSYeyfN-Nv;NQ[ eSxQ~Nmf[-NN,GWatS1udk>muv ^:W1Yup b:N-NVNN?eV{v;NtW@x0N(uNN?eV{v;Ntceg w [N?e^[hQOo`T[hQt'`MRcvS[g:N:_p :NsSO(Wt NX[(W ^:W1Yup NNN?eV{\O(uvzz FO/f(Ws[-N1uN?e^v^ Nb g@bv[Oo` NS6R[T[ecknxv?eV{r^ NN?eV{ Te؏O&^eg%N͑vP%T[y0ُNc[NmeQƋTS`NN?eV{eu/fsQ͑v0ُNxvzY(WeSxQtvFhg NƖ-NN?e^1YupvtRg [N ^:W1Yup SvQv^t\NNckbV^ ُv^ NasT@w ^:W1Yup SvQt NX[(Wt Nv:w0[E N eSxQt[N^:W:g6Rv{USt O_ ^:W1Yup KNN NS_vtaINT?eV{+TIN0eY0W)Rf[>m(WWN[^:W:g6RN^:WǏ zmeQ㉐gvW@x N [N ^:W1Yup SvsQtcQN:_ gRv(uTyb$R ُ(W_'Y z^ NRGdNsNNN?eV{tv9h,g06q ُN(uTyb$R(W_'Y z^ N:NNN?eV{vxvz$\vQ/f-NVvNN?eV{xvz @b_eu0s^`2005 (WvQW\O-N ~T;`~NeY0W)R~Nmf[>m^:WǏ ztSvQ[ ^:W1Yup tvyb$R ُN͑vW\Ov^l g_w-NVvNN?eV{xvz^ gv͑Ɖ0,geN{eY0W)Rf[>m^:WǏ "&*.0>@BVbft|* , J |jYH:H:H:H:Hh@PB*OJaJo(ph h Eh@PB*OJaJo(ph!h@P5B*OJQJaJo(ph"h@PB*CJOJQJaJo(phhok5CJ aJ o($jhokhok0J5CJUaJ(hh9B*CJOJQJaJo(ph"hB*CJOJQJaJo(ph(hhB*CJOJQJaJo(ph%h5B*CJ,OJQJaJ,o(ph+hh5B*CJ,OJQJaJ,o(ph BVX *\f$ hG$H$WDXD2YD2`a$gdJ7G$H$WDXD2YD2`$7$8$G$H$WDXD2YD2`a$$G$H$WDXD2YD2`a$gd@P$7$8$G$H$XD2YD2a$gd@P WDX`gdok$7$8$G$H$XD2YD2a$gd9 J R T Z   J P F ξξξ᭛zl^lRlhZizB*OJQJphhHXB*OJQJo(phhZizB*OJQJo(phhZiz5B*CJOJQJph!hZiz5B*CJOJQJo(ph"hHXB*CJOJQJaJo(ph!hh@PB*OJPJQJphh@PB*OJQJaJo(ph$heh@PB*OJQJaJo(ph h Eh@PB*OJaJo(phh@PB*OJaJo(ph  ( ,.8<ҍn`PB6hZizB*OJQJphhHXB*OJQJo(phhHXB*OJQJ^Jo(phhHXB*OJQJ^Jph!hHXhHXB*OJQJ^JphhZizB*OJQJ^Jph!hHXhHXB*OJQJ^Jph"hZizB*KHOJQJaJo(phhZizB*KHOJQJaJph"hUB*KHOJQJaJo(ph"hHXB*KHOJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJo(phhUB*OJQJo(ph ",:<BDFRZT\jz|*.ͺݬݞ̀rdrVV̀E!hZ5B*CJOJQJo(phhZizB*OJQJ^JphhUB*OJQJo(phhHXB*OJQJo(phhZizB*OJQJo(phh B*OJQJ^Jo(phhUB*OJQJ^JphhHXB*OJQJ^Jph$hHXhHXB*OJQJ^Jo(phhZizB*OJQJ^Jo(phhHXB*OJQJ^Jo(ph$hHXhHXB*OJQJ^Jo(ph.Z\$@BXZbLNTZJb&\^02P^npûyk`k`kyk`k`k`k`hJ7OJQJaJo(hH9hJ7OJQJaJo(hH9hJ7OJQJh.2hJ7OJQJo((hVhJ75B*KHOJQJaJph+hVhJ75B*KHOJQJaJo(phhJ7OJQJhJ7OJQJo(hH9hJ7OJQJo($hJ7hJ75B*CJOJQJph'hJ7hJ75B*CJOJQJo(ph%\BZ!!#~'+--25|7$<V<? hG$H$WDXD2YD2`$ hG$H$WDXD2YD2`a$$7$8$G$H$WDXD2YD2`a$gdJ7 hG$H$WD`gdJ7 . 4 b d f ~ @!T!!!!!!!""""##V#f#ȻȰȻȰznbhMhJ7OJQJo(h/BKhJ7OJQJo(hwhJ7OJQJ(hVhJ75B*KHOJQJaJph+hVhJ75B*KHOJQJaJo(phhJ7OJQJaJo(hH9hJ7OJQJaJhH9hJ7OJQJaJo(hH9hJ7OJQJhJ7OJQJo(hH9hJ7OJQJo(hJ7OJQJaJ#f##$$v&z&|&&&&|'~'''h((() ))):)<)>)P)l)r))))**++,,,----ݴԴԴݞݍݞ݀ݞj+hVhJ75B*KHOJQJaJo(phjh41hJ7H*U h1^#hJ7B*OJQJo(phh41hJ7OJQJhH9hJ7OJQJhH9hJ7OJQJo(h/BKhJ7OJQJo(hJ7OJQJhJ7OJQJo(h41hJ7OJQJo(hMhJ7OJQJo(hMhJ7OJQJ(-------B/F/R/V/n///`0.1n12222445j55z77776888:8<888888888::"<$<uh5hJ7OJQJo(hT7hJ7OJQJo(hJ7OJQJhH9hJ7OJQJhe&hJ7OJQJo(hH9hJ7OJQJo(hJ7OJQJo((hVhJ75B*KHOJQJaJph+hVhJ75B*KHOJQJaJo(ph%hJ75B*KHOJQJaJo(ph-$<&<T<V<f<=======? ??????ͽyfUGGG6!hZiz5B*OJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJph!hZizB*OJQJ\aJo(ph%hXB*OJQJ\^JaJo(phhZizB*OJQJ^JaJph"hZizB*OJQJ\^JaJph"hZizB*OJQJ^JaJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJo(phhHXB*OJQJaJo(phhZiz5B*CJOJQJph!hZiz5B*CJOJQJo(ph!hJ75B*CJOJQJo(ph??@@@@@@@@@@@@@@AAA A(A2AAAAAvcRBBhZizB*OJQJ\aJph!hXB*OJQJ\aJo(ph%h B*OJQJ\^JaJo(ph%h.B*OJQJ\^JaJo(ph"h.B*OJQJ\^JaJph%hZizB*OJQJ\^JaJo(ph"hZizB*OJQJ\^JaJph!hZizB*OJQJ\aJo(phhZiz5B*OJQJaJph!hZiz5B*OJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJo(ph?@CGbLLNMhMQQTX|\\ ](]$ hG$H$WDXD2YD2`a$ hG$H$WDXD2YD2`$7$8$G$H$WDXD2YD2`a$ hG$H$WDXD2YD2`$ hG$H$WDXD2YD2`a$AlBpBtBBBBBBBBCCCCC$C&CrCCCCCsaO;O&hZizB*KHOJQJ^JaJo(ph#hZizB*KHOJQJ^JaJph"hZizB*KHOJQJaJo(ph%hXB*OJQJ\^JaJo(ph%hZizB*OJQJ\^JaJo(ph"hZizB*OJQJ\^JaJphhZizB*OJQJ\aJph"h{]5B*OJQJ\^JaJph!hZB*OJQJ\aJo(phhZB*OJQJ\aJph!hZizB*OJQJ\aJo(phCCCCCCCCCGG$G&G.GGGGGHH~IIJ,J.K:K쯙ڇwgUgggggA&hZizB*KHOJQJ\^JaJph"hXB*KHOJQJaJo(phhZizB*KHOJQJaJphhZizB*OJQJ\aJph"hZizB*KHOJQJaJo(ph*hZizB*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJph-hZizB*CJKHOJQJ\^JaJo(ph&hXB*KHOJQJ^JaJo(ph#hZizB*KHOJQJ^JaJph&hZizB*KHOJQJ^JaJo(ph:KL@LHLJLRLTL^L`LbLLLLMNMfMhMNNO첝|l\N\N\>\h B*OJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJphhZizB*OJQJaJo(phhZiz5B*OJQJaJph!hZiz5B*OJQJaJo(phhZizB*KHOJQJaJph)hZizB*KHOJQJ\^JaJo(ph&hZizB*KHOJQJ\^JaJph&hsB*KHOJQJ^JaJo(ph#hZizB*KHOJQJ^JaJph&hZizB*KHOJQJ^JaJo(phO&O0O2OOOQQQQQQS,S.S6SSSSST TTTpU~UUUUUUyyyiYh.B*OJQJaJo(phh B*OJQJaJo(ph"hsB*KHOJQJaJo(ph"hZizB*KHOJQJaJo(phhZizB*KHOJQJaJphhZizB*OJQJaJph(jhZiz0JB*OJQJUaJphh;UB*OJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJo(phh kB*OJQJaJo(phUU2V4VZVnV|VWWWWWWW:WX(X2X^XXXXX Y:Y`!hWB*OJQJ\aJo(ph!hiB*OJQJ\aJo(ph!hZizB*OJQJ\aJo(phhZizB*OJQJ\aJph"hZizB*KHOJQJaJo(phhZizB*KHOJQJaJphhZizB*OJQJaJo(phhZiz5B*OJQJaJph!hZiz5B*OJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJphhZizB*OJQJo(phhZiz5B*CJOJQJphz```````dalapaaaa>e@eee(fffggggghhhhhhͿͿ͓vfͿ͓ͿͿͿͿfU!h}Q5B*OJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJ\aJph!hZizB*OJQJ\aJo(phhZizB*OJQJphhZizB*OJQJo(phh!DBB*OJQJaJphh!DBB*OJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJphhZizB*OJQJaJo(ph"hZizB*KHOJQJaJo(phhZizB*KHOJQJaJph(]a@ehhkrmnphsvx@{p{{$7$8$G$H$WDXD2YD2`a$ hG$H$WDXD2YD2`gd}Q hG$H$WDXD2YD2`gdm hG$H$WDXD2YD2`gdJ7 hG$H$WDXD2YD2` hhhhhhhhi$j(j8j@jDjFjHjTj^jjjrjtjjjjj`kkkͽooo___Oh}QB*OJQJaJo(phh[PB*OJQJaJo(phh?B*OJQJaJo(phh-B*OJQJaJo(phhmB*OJQJaJo(phh!DBB*OJQJaJphh=VNB*OJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJo(phhJ75B*OJQJaJph!h}Q5B*OJQJaJo(ph!hJ75B*OJQJaJo(phklpnpvvxx@{B{D{F{n{p{{{{{{{hvɶuugYMYMY?h B*OJQJo(phhZizB*OJQJphhZizB*OJQJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJphh}B*OJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJo(ph"hZiz5B*KHOJQJaJphhZiz5B*OJQJo(ph%hZiz5B*KHOJQJaJo(ph%h}Q5B*KHOJQJaJo(ph!h}Qh}QB*OJQJaJph$h}Qh}QB*OJQJaJo(ph{0`(V,{a hG$H$WDXD2YD2`gd}Q$7$8$G$H$WDXD2YD2`a$gd}Q$7$8$G$H$WDXD2YD2`a$ h@&G$H$WDXD2YD2`$-D1$G$H$M WDXD2YD2`a$7$8$@&G$H$WDXD2YD2` @BJޅf \T`fhjdfJL,.0涭||k`RkhuhZizOJQJaJo(hmOJQJaJo( huhZizB*OJQJo(ph#jhZizB*H*OJQJUphh B*OJQJo(phhZizOJQJh OJQJo(hZizOJQJo("hZizB*KHOJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJphhZizB*OJQJphhZizB*OJQJo(ph 02^`(*,>HJRTVXғHt|ǹ{{{{iWG9GWh}QB*OJQJo(phh}QB*OJQJaJo(ph"h}QB*KHOJQJaJo(ph"h{!B*KHOJQJaJo(ph!h}Q5B*CJOJQJo(ph!h{!5B*CJOJQJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJphhZizB*OJQJo(ph"hZiz5B*KHOJQJaJph%hZiz5B*KHOJQJaJo(ph%h}Q5B*KHOJQJaJo(ph zf[>m(uNyb$R^:W1Yuptv;N‰p0 1eY0W)Rf[>mv^:W‰NzN‰ (WeY0W)Rf[>mWNe0wƋTN{|L:NvƋ \^:Wt:NR`vN܀zNǏ zNc"}0SsvǏ z0^:WǏ z/fN*N OdT)R(uwƋv:_ gR:g6R R*NN[~b:gOTǏNf)R(u:gONXRuNTm9v\o(WLuTƖT0^:WzNwckvNm:N NNN,GWatv^s[agN:NSgq$Rew[NLu-N^:WЏLHes _N NNN,GWatvY`HeshQegaϑR`^:WvHes0OnceSxQN,GWa!jWvt`r`Sċ$Rs[-Nv^:WHes s[^:WN^/}XbgOr`evGPagN]_'Y s[^:W/f:N:ONHes ?e^r^vzz'Y0w[NLȗv^:W NSn^/}XbgOevGPagN eSxQtvُyHesċ$RhQ Q(W+TNُ7hvNyODnvgOMnS_\O^:WvR0eSxQ~Nmf[ ǏǏR%Nm weg ~Nm N/f[hQwƋGP NvDnMn /fwƋSsN)R(uHayek 1945 0^:W:g6RT^:WǏ zvR(WNSswƋ [wQ gRcewƋvyNLRRNOS N gHe)R(uRcewƋ0㉳QwƋ ǏO_^:WSNEQR)R(uN`Nbc:gOۏ [sR`Hes0eSxQ~Nmf[Fhg Nv^:W1Yupt NO0ON^:WǏ zvSsTibcewƋKNǏ z:g6RvRϑ l g w0R^:WvR`Hes'`0eSxQtǏRsQlNwpT~pvY`Rg NlNY`vMnHes0 s[zNǏ z_[/fN*NR`Ǐ z N܀zNR`Ǐ zMb[sR`Hes0(Wq|_yr1999 weg eSxQvN,GWa!jWSvQ^/}XbgOr` ,g(/fY`v0S^:WNSzNv N~NmۏekN~NmX Nv[ l gDm^:Wtvq_T :NOS1Yupv;v^ Nfr^;NINvTt'` ^:W:g6R(WOSebv1Yupv^ NasT@w NasT@w?e^^S_r^0SV(WN[N^:WOS1Yupv$Re/fOnc NS0Rvt`hQ N{Џ(uUOyOS:g6R OS1YupnfMX[(W0~gq\ۏNekcQ ՋVf^:WOS1Yupvt!jWS/f{USba GPX[(W[Oo` s[NLub4NvOS/f^8^ YBgv ~Nm;NSOSwQ g@\wƋ ُy^!je_[cؚN*N~Nmf[[vb g@bv FO/fbُy!jW\O:Nw[NLuv[tec NS$Res[vhQTQ?eV{vOnc 1\ONu[0 3 ^:W1Yup t/f[w[NLu^:W~NmЏLvf㉌T (WeY0W)Rf[>m^:WǏ zt weg N,GWaFhg Nv^:W1YupvsQtl gwckƋ0R^:WN^:WǏ zv'`(TN

PTN:N:gOevON[SsT)R(u0ck/fN܀zN'`ON[vSsǏ z O_^:WY gHeЏL v^cR~NmvgX0eSxQaIN Nv ^:W1Yup sa [E Nck}Y/f^:W gHeЏ\OTS%cHesvwQSO:g6RNb__0@bv ^:W1Yup /fR`Nw[^:WǏ z-Nv8^` ^:WQuvTy wm:N ~Nmf[vW,g/fRce(W*NNKNvwƋYUO_NOSv N܀zNv^:WǏ z /fďN:NbkN{|SsTRcewƋg gHev:g6Rs^` 2005 0 fۏNekv Kirzner2000 R:N^:W@\Pv^^NUO ^:W1Yup sa /f:ON^:WX[(Wv6R[MRc ^:W(WS%cKQ gwƋebvRN*g1Y%Ǐ  ^:W1Y% t@b+Tv^:Wꁫ:w [E N/f`avTR,v0@b ^:W@\P v^^NUOb__v ^:W1Yup v^^^:W,gX[(W@\PN N vQ[(/f^:WVNX[(Wv6R^MRcv1Y%0:ON^:WKNYv6R^ N܀zN^:WǏ z1\elQs0^:Wwckv@\P(WNY@\P 6R^1Yup/fk ^:W1Yup fTvi_s^` 2005 0 (WeY0W)Rf[>m weg Y'`/fQuN^:WǏ zv_6qsa0Y'`v,g((WN:ONQ'`vFhg (WN6R^W@xQs1Y% N/f^:WǏ zelSsT)R(uRcewƋN㉳QY N~Nm v^^^:WǏ zRg-Nv ^:W1Yup 0ckY'` NǏ/f^:WǏ zeav0Yv~g NRckY'`SOsN*NNHesT>yOHesN v^^ ^:W1Yup vwQSOhs0 R`vck Y'`1\/f^:WǏ zSswƋ0ibcewƋNRewƋv|~h0[E N eSxQaIN NvY'`SvQ[v ^:W1Yup ;NSV(WNCg)RLu[ NS_ O_Y'`QSvb,gǏؚ TvNCg~gY[sY'`vQS0Y'`SvQ[v ^:W1Yup ^勫t:NCg)RRYLu[QsN0[N^:W [ONuYvoR (W~[vRYCg)R~g N O_:gOev^:WSNSb_bTy~~eg9eSCg)Rvv[Lu N[sY'`GS N 0RN`T\Ovvv ^:Wꁫv^ NX[(W@b1Yups^` 2005 0 Oo` N[hQNOo` N[y/fw[NLu^:W~Nm-Nv8^` v^ NO[@bv ^:W1Yup 0Neb gNePOo` N[hQTOo` N[yv^ N[^:WǏ z-NvNfb_b[('`x0SNebck/f_{~1u^:WǏ zvU\_ Oo`Mb NeSs0ibcev^N(WNfTe[sR`vv[GWa0^:WǏ z,g1\/fOo`TwƋibceǏ z ^:WǏ zꁫYQuQTy㉌TKQ gOo`v㉳QRl0^:WǏ z-NvOo`^FO NO;x^:WS%cvQR S ck/f^:WǏ z_NU\_vRRTnl /fwƋR]MRc N㉳QOSv^:Wy^_NQsvMRcs^` 2005 0 eY0W)Rf[>mvf[ Te؏[eSxQFhg N Oo`Yn N^:W1YupcQN:_pv(uTyb$R0(WeY0W)Rf[>mvf[ weg ^:WOo`bwƋ;`/f;N‰v v^N NS/f~[v V:N[N/fON[aƋ0R)Rm:gOe NeR uNQegv0ON[N NeSSvNe~g_‰{6R0ek^zN[U^:W6R^SO| bU\^:WOSvzz0X:_^:WvOSR ۏ OۏNNvgeP^SU\0ُbN(WEQRƋ^:W:g6R0^:WN?e^sQ|vW@x N ͑gNXۏNibU\^:W:NSTvNN?eV{tSO|0 1XۏNibU\^:W:NN?eV{-N?e^N^:WsQ|v͑eϑ ͑gNN?eV{vtSO| HQNt NmeQƋ^:WN?e^vsQ| tnNN?eV{6R[T[eǏ z-N?e^L:NvLu fnx?e^SNǑS?eV{KbkvƖT0(W/ec?e^r^WNN?eV{vv^t-N ^:WN?e^/f^dksS|_vvN[zNfNvsQ| (W@b ^:W1Yup vW ?e^^vcr^^:WNfN^:W06q ^:WN?e^v^^|_dkce0[zNvNfNv{USsQ| /f YBgNR-NvNesQ|s^` 2005 0ُyNesQ|;NSOs(W?e^_{cO^:W:g6R gHeЏl@bOVvW@x6R^Fhg v^ NeXۏNibU\^:W0 ^:WT?e^/fNev V[_{:N^:WcOTv6R^W@xChhibber 1997 0NLuL1997t^(W 0SiNLu-Nv?e^ 0-NcQ ^:WN?e^/fvvbv (W:N^:W^z[v6R^W@xeb ?e^/f NSb:v0~'YYpebRvO /f?e^T^:Wb_bNeT\OsQ|NfNzNsQ|v~g0?e^:NsN^:WvX[(WN gHeЏLcOTv6R^Fhg0?e^CgR/fOb*NNCg)Rg gHev]wQ wQ g]'Yvĉ!j~Nm0?e^cOv6R^W@xN6R^Fhg $\vQ/fNCgُ7hvW@x6R^ /f~NmA~c NSb:vagNKeefer and Shirley 2000 0(WSU\-NV[ ?e^g:N͑vL1\/f^z^:W~NmЏLvT6R^W@xT6R^Fhg v^Oۏ^:WSO|vS0?e^cOv6R^Fhg SbLu[v^Ob"NCg)R OlQckQY~_NgbL ~bl_Ny^ cOhQ'^ cO gP#NvlQS6R^[c ĉ[4xN z^ OD,g^:Wvg3z[S gHeЏlI{I{0 Te (Wte*N6R^Fhg-N ?e^_{S0R~_g NOV[lQCgR Nn(u nxO?e^ NOOrlQlv"NTCg)R0?e^cOv6R^Fhg؏_{OT~b^:Wv_>e'`01uT_>e'`/f^:W[svQR`HesvW,gagN /fOON[SsT)R(u^:W:gOg:NW@x'`vMRc0WON[|^y_NlS:Ns[LRv1u~NmsX /fO~Nmc~Xv8h_0Yg:ON1u NAQLR;NSOwQ gۏeQNNT^:Wv1u bCg)R 1\ NS[swckaIN Nv~Nmc~SU\s^` 2005 0 ?e^(WXۏNibU\^:WebwQ gsQ.\O(u0eY\hOlson R NN*Nؚ^Sm)vQgXtv͑i_  :_S^:WW?e^market-augmenting government 0N*N?e^Yg gYvCgRSR TObyNCg)R v^NY:_6RgbLTyQY~ Ndk Te [؏S0R~_g eleR:YbOryNCg)R HNُ*N?e^1\/f :_S^:WW?e^ 0:_S^:WW?e^v8h_/fibU\^:W:gOvƖTNV ibU\^:W;NSOSsN)R(u\o(W:gOv bzz g'YS0WoSON[vRNp`v^Oۏ~Nmvc~Xs^` 2005 0NgoĖT~7QON2002 N;N _?e^(WeEQNibU\^:Webv͑\O(u :_[e^:W:gib _'`?eV{v_'`0(WNN weg ^:W/f1ulegOS v^1ulOSV[0nfS b_bv6R^@beEQ[U NSQ(W0WwQYǏie[svQR`'`DnMnؚHesvRϑ0?e^^S%c ib _^:W:g v\O(u Ng'YP^0WS%c^:WNl6R^v~T [sR`'`DnMnv\O(u OۏlOSfRz)RۏL0?e^vW@x'`L _N^1ueSxQFhg-NvwckNfN^:W lS:N~bNibU\^:W ibU\*NSO bv:gOƖTN^:WV0?e^L:N@bwQ gvR`Hesyr_ _N;NǏ9eUTibU\^:WhsQegs^` 2005 0 NN N N wQ XۏNibU\^:WW?e^tN^:WXۏX[(W$N*N͑:S+R,{N ^:WXۏ:NSU\-NV[^:WOSV /f^:WꁫX[(Wv:w sS/f^:W1Yup XۏNibU\^:WW?e^t:N SU\-NV[^:WOSV/f1uN^:W6R^:1YTsL~NmSO6Rv:w0,{N N?eV{ Neg w ^:WXۏN6qՋVǏN[ z^vr^Nmbf^:WegOۏl;NSOKNvOSXۏNibU\^:WW?e^tR:_ ?e^_{cO^:WVN gHeЏlv6R^Fhg ?e^^S_ Ne[U^:WSO6RTbU\^:W\O(uV v^NdkXۏ^:WOSR [s^:WvR`vHes0 2-NVs6k[eNXۏNibU\^:W:NSTvNN?eV{wQ g͑aIN SU\-NV[(WlWTSU\vǏ z-N (WXۏNibU\^:W?eV{ebwQ g͑\O(u0SU\-NV[(WSU\Rg^:WSO6R_ NePhQ [^:W(WOSNOۏ~NmSU\Ǐ z-NX[(W%N͑vx0egSU\~Nmf[e.sYncdk:N SU\-NV[X[(W%N͑v ^:W1Yup sa ;N _?e^vcr^TfN^:Wegcۏ~NmSU\0cSv^[edk{|?eV{^vSU\-NV[ RgHegf 6q @w~NmSU\Ǐ zvcۏ teSOSU\~He%`gR NM DnMnHesv`S v^[gvQ%N͑v?e^1Yup0-NV>yO~Nmvc~_SU\ ؏_{OVN^:WSO6Rv^zT Ne[U0 6q ^:W6R^v^zN[US/fN*NnۏToSvǏ z vNT|v0Nev6R^Ǐ|_dk^'`f[`N Mbnb:N gHev6R^Fhg0(Wُ*NǏ z-N NN?eV{@bwQ gvؚ^9_'`OvQSNb:NcR^:W6R^oۏv͑]wQ ǏNN?eV{v6R[0[eTte SsN^:WSy^vNv6R^ v^\vQ\O:Nck_l_nxzv^ibce0\O:Ncۏ^:W6R^oۏ]wQvNN?eV{ S/fXۏNibU\^:W:NST [_{ \͑^:Wy^N^:WoSǏ z-NvSRϑ RNWTOb^:WQTySTQuRϑvb cOON[_NEQRS%cv[~gsX Teg'YP^0WQ\?e^L:Nva'`0 ^:WSO6R N[UNSSO6R9eiS; O_^:W(WcR~NmlWNNN~gte-NvW@x'`\O(uTR`HesNS%c0V s6kl:N[eNXۏNibU\^:W:NSTvNN?eV{ wQ g͑s[aIN0NN?eV{\O:NwQ g9_'`v0㉳Q~NmЏLNOHesv]wQ X:_vQ(WcR^:W6R^ePhQT[Uebv\O(u :N^:W:g6Rv gHeЏLcOW@x6R^O0NN?eV{v͑p^l:N~b^:W:g6R X:_^:W:g ibU\^:WV Oۏ^:WzN NnxO^:WzN NS0R?e^r^vmbf nxO^:W(WlQs^0_>evsX-Nf gHeЏL0 3XۏNibU\^:WWNN?eV{v;NQ[TW,gSR (W^:W~NmSO6R-N ^:WǏvQNe~gv^nSm[N_‰~Nmv^lr^T{6R ib'Y~Nm;NSOv1u^$\vQ/fۏeQ0Q^:WT;NbDv1u^ Oۏ^:WzN v^NnxO^:W_>e'`,{N ekcۏSO6R9ei v^^zN[Uv^^:W 6R^ NEQRS%c^:W\O(uN^:WOSvR`Hes,{ N 6R[T[eOۏ-NN:ggeP^SU\vv^?eV{N6R^ cؚ^:W;NSO;NOSR,{V ePhQT[UwƋNCg6R^ R:_wƋNCgvOb R:_b/gRevoR:g6R,{N \NN?eV{v͑p1u  uNOHQ l:N~bm9Cgv ǏR[~bm9CgvN ~[qR:g6R cR^:WeP^SU\,{mQ [NNNNW@xyf[b/gxvzvONۏLnfM'`/ec RQcI{~rNTm9,{N 9eis gvsXObSO6R OsXObvsQlĉv%Ne~g{6Rv TecR~NmSO6R9ei Xۏ^:W:gNibU\^:WV ekpT ĉRf0lQckgblvll~Nm zN'`vsN^:W~NmSO6R 0 [Se.s] Amsden, A.H. Asia's Next Giant, 1989: South Korea and Late Industrialization. New York: Oxford University Press. Amsden, A.H., 1994:  Why isn't the whole world experimenting with the East Asian model to develop?: Review of the East Asian miracle . World Development, Vol.22, 4:627-633. Beason, R., Weinstein, D.E., 1996:  Growth, economies of scale, and targeting in Japan (1955 1990) . Review of Economics and Statistics, 78:286 295. Brander, J.A, Spencer, B.J., 1983: Strategic Commitment with R&D: The Symmetric Case . The Bell Journal of Economics.Vol. 14, No.1:225-235. Brander, J.A, Spencer, B.J., 1985:  Export subsidies and international market share rivalry . Journal of International Economics.Vol.18(1-2):83-100. Chhibber, A.,1997:  The state in changing world .Finance and development. 34(3):11-33. Foray, L., Bertrand, C., Pinguet, F., Soulier, M., Astre, C., Marion, C., Plissier, Y., Bessire J. M.,1999:  In vitro cytotoxic activity of three essential oils from Salvia Species . J Essent Oil Res. 1: 522-526. Hayek,1945:  The Use of Knowledge in Society . American Economic Review.XXXV: 519 530. Helpman, E., Krugman, P.,1989: Trade Policy and Market Structure. Cambridge, MA:MIT Press. Hausman, R., Rodrik, D.,2003:  Economic Development as Self-Discovery . Journal of Development Economics. Vol.72. Heo,Uk, Sunwoong Kim, 2000:  Financial Crisis in South Korea: Failure of the Government-led Development Paradigm . Asian Survey. 40(3):492-507. Hobbs, C., Lee, L., Driedger, L, 1991:  Implementing Multicultural Policy: An Analysis of the Heritage Language Program, 1971-81 .Canadian Public Administration. Vol.34(4): 664-675. Ito,T., 1994:  [The East Asian Miracle: Four Lessons for Development Policy]: Comment . NBER Macroeconomics Annual. Vol. 9:274-280. Johnson, C.A., 1982: MITI and the Japanese Miracle. Chicago: Stanford University Press, 1982. Keefer, P., Shirley, M.,2000:  Formal versus informal institutions in economic development .In: Claude MNARD (ed). , Intuitions, Contracts and Organizations: Perspective from New Institutional Economics, Edward Elgar, 88-107. Kirzner, I.M.,2000:  The Driving Force of the Marke . Essays in Austrian Economics. London & New York: Routledge. Klimenko, M.,2004:  Industrial Targeting, Experimentation and Long-run Specialization . Journal of Development Economics.73. Klinger, B., Lederman, D.,2004:  Discovery and Development: An Empirical Exploration of  New Products . World Bank Policy Research.Working Paper No.3450. Krueger, A.O.,1974:  The Political Economy of the Rent-Seeking Society . The American Economic Review.64, 3: 291-303. Krueger, A. O., B. Tuncer., 1982:  An Empirical Test of the Infant Industry Argument . American Economic Review. 72/5: 1142-1152. Krugman, P.,1997:  What Ever Happened to the Asian Miracle? . Forture.Vol. 136(4): 26-29. Lall, S.,1997: Learning from the Asian Tigers: Studies in Technology and Industrial Policy. New York: St. Martin's Press. Lall, S.,2001:  Comparing National Competitive Performance . Queen Elizabeth House Working Paper Series. No. S61. Laussel, D., Montet, C., Peguin-Feissolle, A.,1988:  Optimal trade policy under oligopoly : A calibrated model of the Europe-Japan rivalry in the EEC car market . European Economic Review. Vol. 32(7): 1547-1565. Lavoie, D.R., 1985: Central Planning: The Socialist Calculation Debate Reconsidered. New York: Cambridge University Press. Little, Ian M. D.,1982: Economic Development. New York: Basic Books. Okuno-Fujiwara,1988:  Interdependence of industries, coordination failure and strategic promotion of an industry . Journal of International Economics.Vol.25(1-2): 25-43. Pack, H., 2000:  Industrial Policy: Growth Elixir or Poison? . The World Bank Research Observer.Vol. 15, No.1:47-67. Pack, H., Saggi, K.,2001:  Vertical technology transfer via international outsourcing . Journal of Development Economics.Vol. 65(2):389-415. Pack, H., Westphal, L.,1986:  Industrial Strategy and Technological Change: Theory versus Reality . Journal of Development Economics.22: 87-128. Powell, B., 2005:  State Development Planning: Did it Create an East Asian Miracle? . The Review of Austrian Economics.Vol.18,3:305-323. Rodrik, D.,1996:  Corodination Failures and Government Policy: A Model with Applications to East Asia and Eastern Europe . Journal of International Economics.40: 1-22. Rodrik, D.,2004:  Industrial Policy For The Twenty-First Century . Paper prepared for UNIDO. www.ksg.harvard.edu/rodrik/, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Boston, September. Rodrik, D.,2008:  Normalizing Industrial Policy . The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, The Commission on Growth and Development Working Paper Series. Stiglitz, J.E. Jaramillo-Vallejo, J., Park, Y.C. The role of the state in financial markets[J], World Bank Research Observer, Annual Conference on Development Economics Supplement,1993:19-61. Stiglitz, J.E.,2001:  From Miracle To Crisis To Recovery: Lessons From Four Decades of East Asian Experience . in Rethinking the East Asian miracle. edited by Joseph Stiglitz and Shahid Yusuf. Oxford: Oxford University Press: 520-537. Trezise, P.H.,1983:  Industrial policy is not the major reason for Japan's success .  HYPERLINK "http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublication?journalCode=brookrev" \o "The Brookings Review" The Brookings Review. 3. Wade, R., 2004: Governing the Market: Economic Theory and the Role of Government in East Asian Industrialization. Princeton: Princeton University Press. Wolf, Martin,2007:  The Growth of Nations . Financial Times. 21. World Bank,1991: World Development Report 1991The Challenge of Development. Oxford: Oxford University Press. World Bank,1997: World Development Report, 1997: The State in a Changing World. Washington, D.C., World Bank. l ^_" $\ }y 2003 eCSt^vNNGY }N~_t+Y" E" ey0 WyQblm^:Wy^NON[R '` 0 -Nы,g mg] Ym_l'Yf[QHr>y0 _l\m 1999 0SO6RlhegvX0~HeNNN~~vSS[-NVr^LNv[xvz 0 Nwm NwmNlQHr>y0 Nwm NTQHr>y0 _l\m 1996 0~NmlhegvNN?eV{[-NV~v[RgNMRofU\g 0 Nwm NwmNlQHr>y0 _lޘm HORI{ 2007 bDĉ6R?eV{v:wN NoHe^  WN-NV]Nv[ 0-NV]N~Nm 0 ,{6g0 _lޘm NgSf 2010 vcr^^:WNP6RzN-NVNN?eV{vSTN9h,g: 0-NV]N~Nm 0 ,{9g0 _lޘm 2008 0-NV]NNǏiRxvz 0 l -NWS'Yf[0 _lޘm f^wm 2009 ^:W1Yup؏/fSO6Rmbf  ͑ Y^b_b:gtxvz-NvN0:wNeۏU\ 0-NV]N~Nm 0 ,{1g0 &qVNS _lޘm H8 2007 -NVONvv[HesNĉ!jHes 0-NV]N~Nm 0 ,{10g0 NN$N 1998 ~TċKNN }N\[*YΐI{}W 0e,gvNN?eV{ 0 -Nы,g VEeSQHrlQS0 Ngs^ {l _lޘm 2012 ۏeQQ0zNN-NV]N蕄vuNs  _>ezN\O:NN*NHesXۏǏ z ]\Oe0 Ngs^ _lޘm s[O 2010 ͑pNNte/ctQĉRN?eV{STc 0[‰~Nmxvz 0 ,{10g0 RN& 2008 ^:W_>e0zNNNNۏek  -NV}lfNN30t^SU\-NvNT͑~ 0{tNLu 0 ,{12g0 ёQMcKinnon 1999 0~Nm^:WSv!k^  T^:W~NmǏ!negvёc6R 0 -Nы,g NwmNlQHr\g0 HYPERLINK "http://www.golden-book.com/search/search.asp?key1=%C2%FC%C9%AA%2E%B0%C2%B6%FB%C9%AD" \t "_blank"f_teY\h 2006 0Cg)RNA~c 0 -Nы,g Nwm HYPERLINK "http://www.golden-book.com/search/search.asp?key1=%C9%CF%BA%A3%C8%CB%C3%F1%B3%F6%B0%E6%C9%E7" NwmNlQHr>y0 WSNۏ 1992 0e,gv~NmSU\,{NHr 0 -Nы,g SN ~Nm{tQHr>y0 R(g ff_ QeFz\YKQ eYΑck[ 1998 NN~NmSU\-N?e^\O(uveʑ^:WXۏ }NR(g ff_I{W 0?e^(WNN~NmSU\-Nv\O(uk6R^Rg 0 -Nы,g -NV~NmQHr>y ,{1-42u0 Nnΐ 2002 0e,gNN?eV{v 0 NN~Nmeb>y0 ~gq\lQ~ 1998 0~NmSU\OS 0 }NR(g ff_I{W 0?e^(WNN~NmSU\-Nv\O(uk6R^Rg 0 -Nы,g SN -NV~NmQHr>y ,{149-180u0 s^` 2005 0_‰ĉ6Rtxvz  WN[ck~tvyb$RT\^:W\O:NN*NǏ zvt 0 SN -NV>yOyf[QHr>y0 s^` 2007 0zNNWeǏ zzNtƉ҉vRg 0 SN -NV~Nmyf[QHr>y0 \[*Yΐ eYΑck[I{ 1988 0e,gvNN?eV{ 0 -Nы,g SN VEeSQHrlQS0 eΑx^!kΐ 1988 0NN?eV{v~Nmf[ċN 0 0Vl~NmBg_ 0,{9g0 OCQ͑ 1984 Ock^:W1YupvNN?eV{ \[*YΐI{;N 0e,gvNN?eV{ 0 NN'Yf[QHr>y0 ~_t+Yq|_yr 1999 0D,g;NIN0>yO;NINNl;N 0 -Nы,g SN FURpSfN0 NgoĖ ~7QON 2002 ^:WT?e^vNesQ|  ^:W:gib _'`?eV{v_'` }NR(g ff_I{ 0^:Wv\O(u V[v\O(u 0 -Nы,g SN -NVSU\QHr>y0 _Oޘ _g3 2007 0r^bb Nr^?  V~?e^NN?eV{ gHe'`vN 0 0~Nm>yOSO6Rk 0 ,{4g0 _[q 2010 0.v Nv~Nmf[ 0 Nwm u;mfNew NTfN^0 iIv 2000 0e,gvNN~~tN[MRl 0 SN ~Nm{tQHr>y0  ,ge:NNgs^xvzXT;NcV[>yyWё͑'Ybhyv ͑pNN~gteT/ctQĉRxvz ybQS10zd&026 v6k'`bg0RQ[ShN-NOQHr>y 0k 02012t^,{3g;`,{60 0  0NNteN/ctQĉR 00 0 grё^\NNteN/ctQĉR 0I{͑pNNteN/ctQĉRe,g NS 0sQNb6RRLNNǏiRT͑ Y^_[NNeP^SU\vr^a 00  beu'`8ft:N[e8fOb0z6eQMQ0QSe4I{ObTOۏ|^zNNTbeuNNSU\v?eV{cONtOnc FO/fv^l g:N-NVN^lr^VQ~Nm;NSO_‰~NmL:Nyr_vNN?eV{cOtOnc0  Eaton & Grossman 1986 cQBrander & Spencerv!jW-NvSeYg N/f cǑSSzNve_ /fǑS/O]_zN!j_ HNQSe4 gSw0R[hQvSv\O(u0  Baldwin1992 {]?e^e4EMB-120Џ:gQSv>yOy)R_1Y Ss>yO;`y)RX[(WQ_c1Y0 ~S ws^` 0_‰ĉ6Rtxvz  WN[ck~tvyb$RT\^:W\O:NN*NǏ zvt 0NfNv,{ Nz  ^:W1Y% savN ^:W1Y% v NS'` 0  OCQ͑1988 0 Nnΐ1988 Nc{|@H~DFPX\^̼m__O__h[RB*OJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJph$jhZiz0JB*OJQJUphhZizB*OJQJo(phhZizB*OJQJph"hZizB*KHOJQJaJo(phhZizB*KHOJQJaJphhZizB*OJQJaJo(ph!hZiz5B*CJOJQJ\ph!hZiz5B*CJOJQJo(ph!h{!5B*CJOJQJo(phF^> @6VnBld hG$H$WDXD2YD2`gd hG$H$WDXD2YD2`$7$8$G$H$WDXD2YD2`a$$7$8$G$H$WDXD2YD2`a$ hG$H$WDXD2YD2` ^<>48<BFprxz 𲢲𒂒rbbrQ!h{!5B*CJOJQJo(phhSB*OJQJaJo(phhF B*OJQJaJo(phhB*OJQJaJo(phhB*OJQJaJo(phhrjB*OJQJaJo(phh[PB*OJQJaJo(phhI7B*OJQJaJo(phhUB*OJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJphhZizB*OJQJaJo(ph ,:>@z|46TVlnv@BhͽxhxVxhxA(h{!hZizB*KHOJQJaJo(ph"h-B*KHOJQJaJo(phhZizB*KHOJQJaJph"hZizB*KHOJQJaJo(ph"hZiz5B*KHOJQJaJph%hZiz5B*KHOJQJaJo(phhZizB*OJQJaJphhZizB*OJQJaJo(phhZiz5B*CJOJQJph!h!H5B*CJOJQJo(ph!hZiz5B*CJOJQJo(phl~$& "246:BJbdhڲڛږ}mZ%hZiz5B*KHOJQJaJo(phhB*OJQJaJo(ph hV#o( h C6o( hJ:.o( hPo( h8qo( h(o(,jhl0JB*KHOJQJUaJph"h8qB*KHOJQJaJo(ph+jhZizB*H*KHOJQJUaJph"hZizB*KHOJQJaJo(ph%h{!hZizB*KHOJQJaJphhJNn r   L N x ~   t z   ųšycyNR 8!X"#$%P'4(.)d*P+V, --.01 2`3J4 hG$H$WD`hgd=8FJz|      "!&!4!6!`!n!""6":""""Z#\#####p$t$$$$$$0%2%%%@&B&v& '<'@'j'v'''''L(X(༧ϕ#h=8h=86B*CJaJo(ph(h=8h=8B*CJaJmH o(phsH %h=8h=8B*CJaJmH phsH h=8h=86B*CJaJphh=8h=8B*CJaJph h=8h=8B*CJaJo(ph:X((($)&)`)l))*4*6*~****.+0+++++.,0,l,x,,,,,-&-(--..t.x...@AdB@C DDEpEE\FF6GGGhHH8II G$H$WDgd=8 hG$H$WD`hgd=8,6l6n6660747t7v7777788888 9l9p99d:p:::*;;D=P=>> >N>R>?$?????z@|@@@@@@@AAB6B:BXB\BxBϾh=8h=86CJaJo('h=8h=80J6>*B*CJaJphh=8h=86CJaJ jh=8h=86CJUaJh=8h=8B*CJaJph h=8h=8B*CJaJo(ph h=8h=86B*CJaJph8xBBBBBBTCbCC DDDEEHH6I8IIII>JBJNJRJJJJJJJKKKKKKKLLLLLLϼﮠoooooo&jh=8h=8B*CJUaJphh=8hmB*CJaJphhY*B*CJaJo(phhmB*CJaJo(phh=8B*CJaJo(ph$h=8h=86B*CJQJaJph h=8h=86B*CJaJphh=8h=8B*CJaJph h=8h=8B*CJaJo(ph+IJJJLHMNPNNhOOP`PPQQ0RxRRRS*TTUV aWD`agd}gdJ7G$H$gdok G$H$WD`gd=8 G$H$WDgd=8LFMHMNNPNNNfOhOOOPPQQ.R0RDRRRvRxRRRRRR"S2SSSSSSST T$T&T(TúwwnhhUnHo(tHhhUhJ70JH*hhUhJ70JH*o(hhUhJ70JjhhUhJ70JUhd hokCJaJhd hokCJaJo(hokCJaJo(hokjhok0JUh=8hZizB*OJQJphh=8h=8B*CJaJph h=8h=8B*CJaJo(ph&(T*T,T.TTTTTUUUUVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVNWPWRWTWhW޼՟՟՟՟՟wmahlhl0JH*o(hm-hl0JH*jhm-hl0JH*Uhm-hZiz0JH*jhm-hZiz0JH*UhZiz0JH*nHo(tH h}Q0JH*h}Q0JH*o(jh}Q0JH*UhZiz0JH*mH o(sH hZiz0JH*o( hZiz0JH*jhZiz0JH*UhhUhJ70JnHo(tH"VVVPWWWXXX X XXXXXXX G$H$WD`gd=8 aWD`agdl aWD`agdm- aWD`agd} aWD`agd}QhWjWxW~WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWXXXX XXXXXX߹߹߬rh=8hZizB*OJQJphjh[Uh[h(hlnHo(tHhm-hl0JH*hanHo(tHha0JH*nHo(tHhl&$0JH*nHo(tHjhlhl0JH*Uhm-hm-0JH*hlhl0JH*o(hm-0JH*o(hm-hm-0JH*o( 7182P<0@P. A!"#$%S j" 666666666vvvvvvvvv66666>666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666hH6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666662 0@P`p2( 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p8XV~ OJPJQJ_HmH nHsH tHR`R cke $1$a$(CJKHOJQJ_HaJmH nHsH tH$A $ ؞k=W[SOFiF 0nfh\l_(uH*) ux(&`( l_(uH*^J.U`!. c>*B*`JphFo1F  le,g CharCJKHOJPJQJ^JaJ>oA> u w CharCJOJPJQJ^JaJ>oQ> u CharCJOJPJQJ^JaJ>oa>  >\le,g CharOJPJQJ^JaJDoqD  yblFhe,g CharCJOJPJQJ^JaJ*o* f2 B*`Jphvvv^@^ u w'a$$G$&dP 9r CJKHaJmHsHtH0@0 RQk=WD`B+@B >\le,g a$$G$CJKHmHsHtHL @L ua$$G$ 9r CJKHaJmHsHtH>@> yblFhe,gCJKHaJmHsHtHj@j le,g'XD2YD2a$$G$VD^ CJKHOJQJaJmHsHtH('`( v@ybl_(uCJaJ*@* v@ybleW[ $a$*j@* v@ybl;N!5\PK![Content_Types].xmlN0EH-J@%ǎǢ|ș$زULTB l,3;rØJB+$G]7O٭Vxjm)ʬuWLfdݮ+5_4csj-V?k3rm}gz gs嚋7xwsȈR W*)|jȫKXͫ dXIBF؇bnh ( *'vɗ3KZjz'c*_=}<9ݻw~]8^~_o?xYýg~^G}J0Emh=Ԅ Ξa>s$-, Oɠ=Hp Ua/ UO d*:(.fTU/!9$V[|hrvs-iUt. 6ڪ4Cebs)bMjBekp um,fd$͑{6GUVf~b#Vb@qTTW.ޛd)i@vdq9Y^X7{2%uHx+af6]>f#*qqDᵁ)@?71oggo`:fղekp£2֌Nj8ǰD CB?81e>Է]16褣֧ T$A%BHVac ^qD  J .f#-$<?AC:KOU\z`hk0^ hX(,6xBL(ThWXLNOPQSTUVWYZ[\]^_abde\?(]{,J4IVXMRX`cс:O|nv XXX@ @H 0(  0(  B S  ? OLE_LINK7 OLE_LINK8 OLE_LINK25 OLE_LINK26 OLE_LINK2 OLE_LINK6 OLE_LINK9 OLE_LINK10 OLE_LINK11 OLE_LINK12bfnfn1 OLE_LINK1 OLE_LINK4 OLE_LINK5 OLE_LINK3 OLE_LINK13 OLE_LINK14_GoBack^^TT!&**Z*A+A+  ^^^^dd!&***B+B+ !$,03:(E^adF"*45=C2 & H M    . > b f j t   7 ? K Q R l 8<KOl;4  $T[\]~Y^|0G-/13T\]abhimnvw{|6;dqw}K O !!!!!"" "$"%")"*"/"0"4"G"M"""""""""T#[#a######$$$$$%%%%&&&&&&&&&&&''-'1''''''''(((M(l(s(x(~((((())))Z********B+I+J+N+O+S+T+Y+Z+a+g+++++@,X,b,,,,,,,,,Y-_--.../k/q/////000I0K0L0a0w0|0001@1D1J1O1V1[1`1d1k1t1y11112233:4>455D7L77777U8|89999: : :::*:2::::;;;;;;;;;;<4<A<<<<<Y====>>>$?)?*?3??????????.@@@@*A/A0A4A5A;AIAJAOAAA%BzBBBBBBBBBBBC CCCCCC/CCCCDDEDOD}DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDEE`EdEeEkEEEEEEGGGGHHH"HIIIIKKKKLLQMRM]MMdNNNNOPVPWP\PPPPPPPPQQ6RR#SS!T"TDUEUFUGUVUUUUU?VBVVVVV@NOS{y}$.8su~ۉ)*,68aim܊9=A_aceь [_efjprwx{ !$z}####[,\,,,U-Y---q.x.//==??@@LIOIVVWWYYYY_Z`ZZZ [ []]bbb!b'b*bNcQckkk!kCnEn;o>o{oo'p8pQpVpqqxq}qqqrr=rBrnrrrrrr ssssss7tRtttuuuu#v(vovvvvv.wU]`x[3Rm@uPFqSOrEg@u? Gu=BxT>U]}S[R\IWokwk\y`.+U9X w-#V#l&$(:L*Y*m-J:.,F/B102t4{]5 C6R6I7J7=8 <n?p?=A)>A!DBGVBzC G!H=VN[P@PrQ}Q")R=gT;UWXHXYZ m] kvquRwOgx-yzZizkC~`/S0pU](`B9C>x.z'8qX(tlsDDP-J{!j2YT8s7u/i:aF m/[^0Vi4vZ &HhU[n?jKmy@TUrjF<H`CP`+}v@ A+#{%Lac@T2T2T2T2G xxUnknown G*Ax Times New Roman5Symbol3. *Cx Arial;([SOSimSun;= |8ўSOSimHei7.@ CalibricTimesTen-BoldTimes New RomanSAdobeSongStd-Light[SO?= *Cx Courier New;WingdingsA$BCambria Math AQh' xF 1vGvG2DGF 3q ?'*22! xx Normal r^^:WbbXۏNibU\^:WboHP    Oh+'0x  ( 4 @ LX`hpԤгֻչгboNormalHP12Microsoft Office Word@f`@Q@2sX@6v՜.+,D՜.+, X` Hewlett-Packard CompanyG ([c _PID_HLINKSKSOProductBuildVerAC ]http://www.golden-book.com/search/search.asp?key1=%C9%CF%BA%A3%C8%CB%C3%F1%B3%F6%B0%E6%C9%E743Thttp://www.golden-book.com/search/search.asp?key1=%C2%FC%C9%AA%2E%B0%C2%B6%FB%C9%ADNAhttp://www.jstor.org/action/showPublication?journalCode=brookrev2052-6.6.0.2461  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry FG61TableMWordDocument 9SummaryInformation(DocumentSummaryInformation8MsoDataStore96?6ORB2E4WRNA==296?6Item PropertiesUCompObj n   FMicrosoft Word 97-2003 ĵ MSWordDocWord.Document.89q